This comment section went downhill in a hurry. I’m locking this post for a while.Edit: Unlocked.
?
Edit: Can y’all please stop downvoting this person for being confused? Rule number one. Be kind. They’re not being a dick here or being cruel or anything. Give them the benefit of the doubt please.
JK Rowling is the author of Harry Potter and was primarily known for this. Loved, even, for this. An enormous fanbase. Not to say that there weren’t issues with her portrayal of POC characters or doses of antisemitic behavior (The Goblin Bank literally has a MASSIVE Star of David in the middle of their lobby) but people still loved her nonetheless.
Yet overtime she started adding random stupid things to canon. People asking about bathrooms and her randomly tweeting in response that wizards used to just shit themselves and then magic it all away. This happened more and more with all manner of subjects that started to really point out she was a piece of shit. When people started talking about her portrayal of various different characters, she sort of went off the deep end. She started getting really entrenched in her position and bitter towards everyone. One of these positions was that trans homies are not homies. The typical “mental illness/grooming/rapists” reasoning. Her position within the fandom fell into utter freefall and fractured an enormous amount of said fandom. This then bled into popular culture as a whole because she’s such a popular and influential public figure. She just kept digging and digging and digging and now she’s primarily known online as “That bigoted bitch who wrote the wizard books”. The entire Harry Potter franchise has become slightly toxic to the touch. Hogwarts Legacy was released to immense backlash and almost none of it was the fact that the game was a raging, repetitive and extremely badly written pile of hot garbage that had no character development or story consequences. Even the actor who played Hermione (not sure about others) came out and said that they would have nothing to do with a Harry Potter continuation or reboot if JK Rowling was involved in any way whatsoever which is what led JK and WB to team up to remake the Harry Potter series. There has been a TV show that was announced with JK herself being heavily involved.
While still a massive franchise and a massive fandom, Harry Potter has aggressively slouched in those ratings and has been inextricably linked to the personal opinions of the author formerly known as JK Rowling. Honestly I just refer to her as “that transphobic bitch who wrote about the wizards” most of the time now.
Edit: Fix’d.
Thank you for the very detailed explanation. I knew who she was but not about any of this. I read one or two of the books when they first came out but never really got into it. Also thank you for pointing out that just because someone does not know about the thing you like, does not make them a troll. I just wanted to understand the image.
Hey, you asked. I try my best to be helpful when I can.
Also, of course. I’m trying my best to make this place welcoming for everyone except trolls and bigots. You are neither. I give everyone the benefit of the doubt until given a reason otherwise. Can’t say that I don’t fuck up a lot but I’m trying to help make Lemmy a better place than most other internet rabbitholes.
A nice, civil and wholesome thread, thank you.
No, thank you! With how often I post, I try my best to maintain that. Especially as a mod of [email protected]. Trying to not come off like the mods of that other place.
I’m not defending a lot of what she said but saying that wizards shit themselves and magic it all away is funny
Oh it absolutely is but it’s also just a fucking insane thing to just randomly say
The bathroom thing was just so stupid.
It contradicts the lore of the books.
The entrance to the Chamber of Secrets was literally built in a bathroom. She could have just said it was a Roman style bathroom that was later retrofitted to be modern.
And Dumbledore let’s Harry know about the Room of Requirements by telling a story about how he once needed a chamberpot. A magic chamberpot? Sure. Makes more sense than shitting himself.
Even the actors of Harry and Hermione (not sure about others) came out and said that they would have nothing to do with a Harry Potter continuation or reboot if JK Rowling was involved
Source on this? Curious because the only thing I can find Radcliffe saying is “I’m very excited to see what other people do with it. The comparison I’ve made is to a story like Sherlock Holmes. I think the Potter series of books was always gonna be bigger than one interpretation or one franchise, so it’ll be cool to see the torch get passed on.”
Huh, I can’t find it either. I must have conflated Daniels speaking out against JK with Emma Watsons refusal to ever work with JK again. I’ll edit the post.
Genuinely sorry for that!
No worries. It’s easy to see why you’d get confused :) All the Harry Potter stuff gets conflated in the head sometimes.
I agree with this for the most part, but saying Hogwarts Legacy objectively sucks is just wrong. Most people liked the game, including me (although the main story plot is not great).
deleted by creator
Hogwarts Legacy is rife with problems and those problems are objective. It’s not based on opinion.
It’s so funny when people try to claim that their opinion is objective. Sorry bro, this is still your opinion. LOTS of people enjoyed the game, and if people enjoyed the game safe to say it did its job.
deleted by creator
The basic standards of a game is “is it fun”. If people had fun then it served it’s purpose. Just because you didn’t like it doesn’t mean it’s an objectively bad game. I highly doubt your opinion on the game is free of external biases
deleted by creator
I’m pretty sure what you’re missing here is that you did give (arguably) objective descriptions of issues with the game, but it’s still your opinion that these make the game a failure. Sure, it didn’t meet up to your standards, but those standards are absolutely subjective.
Lots of games are repetitive. Lots of games have no story consequences shown in the game. They still succeed at being games, even if they don’t meet your standards.
I get it, you are passionate about this, but you’re mistaken at this point.
deleted by creator
I like this writeup mushroomdude
Wait… Wasn’t Harry Potter written by Hatsune Miku?
Hogwarts Legacy was a beautiful game. Sucks it’s linked to JK Rowling still
Visually, yes. However the actual gameplay loop becomes hyper repetitive within the space of 2-3 hours and that the plot is genuine garbage that has no resolution or consequences.
I actually think it’s pretty nice but you can tell that it’s been gutted a lot because of time constraints.
I cannot find a single redeeming part of the storyline at all. It’s all hyper contrite, characters motivations/personalities seem to make no sense, the random seasonal jumps are jarring and demonstrate how little characters grow, and the ending literally has no consequence. I chose the ‘evil’ ending and nothing happened outside of that professor dying. Despite absorbing all the ancient energies of doom that these 4 paintings had sealed away, not a single one of them cared despite them insisting on me stopping someone else who was doing precisely the same thing. Despite them saying that no one should have that type of power. I rocked up with said power and they’re just like “Hey Jason.”
I wonder what I shall use my immeasurable ancient power for?
a) Good
b) Evil
c) Shenanigans
d) Literally nothing
Oh, don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying it’s a masterpiece. It’s nice, but could have been way better.
Lol, like she cares what anyone thinks. Lady’s loaded, our opinions are meaningless.
I don’t care that future children will learn that the second most interesting thing about me is that I was hateful, because I have lots of money that will keep my corpse company!
- a liar and/or sociopath
Why should she care what a bunch of terminally online weirdos think about her? She has been extremely successful in her field and demonstrated that a woman can have success in a male dominated industry. Transgenders just hate her because she doesn’t think trans woman are woman because she believes woman means adult human female. That is a reasonable position to hold.
Fuck bigots no matter who.
Removed by mod
It absolutely is
Removed by mod
Removed by mod
Go the fuck back to reddit, transphobe. Literally like 5 people in the fediverse agree with your hateful bullshit.
it couldn’t possibly be less of your dumbfuck business what gender a person was born. Do you ask to inspect genitals when you meet people?
What’s so stupid about these fake origins that conservatives make up is that they pretend two things: 1) people can suddenly develop a new way of being that hadn’t existed before 2) that some dude invented it and then tricked a bunch of people into adopting it… Then just to be further deranged…you just happen to know it was a child molester who did it. Lol but also sad.
Idiotic.
No it isn’t, it is bigoted to say the trans woman aren’t adult human females.
Removed by mod
This dude gets rock hard to ovaries…so manly
Found the bigot!
Curious, why do you think your shitty bigoted dickriding opinion matters? What do you get out of simping for the piece of shit, apart from ire and downvotes?
I don’t think she’s a piece of shit. She inspired a generation of young woman. I don’t think she’s a bigot just because she believes that there is a distinction between males and females.
She and you are bad people. Go back to reddit, troll
Removed by mod
“Isn’t that the lady who does a bunch of racism antisemitism and transphobia?”
“Homer no! That’s JQ Lolling, probably one of the world’s greatest writers!!”
That’s an old episode, no? What did she do back then?
The text is not the actual line from the episode.
Whoa how is that possible!
M a g i c
I think that it’s useful to say it though because it might have been.
Indeed, it’s what happens when the unstoppable force of societal values meets the immovable object of someone’s personal ego.
Removed by mod
The Simpsons writers are experts on being the authors of their own public humiliation - they’ve been doing it for over twenty years now.
Yeah I especially find this post hypocritical because matt groening is a super well known bigot! /s
Lily Simpson did a great video exposé of the Simpson’s passive transphobia. Personally I think a lot of their gay jokes are regressive as well.
Provide an example or go back to Reddit, troll.
JK Rowling is the fucking GOAT
Don’t offend animals.
Keep in mind that lemmy downvotes don’t mean shit and you can just keep on liking her.
lemmy downvotes don’t mean shit
What do you mean? I’m proud of that one comment that I made almost a hundred person mad
